Main menu

11 min read

Holy s**t that’s a lot of plagiarism ๐Ÿ‘€

Way before Design By Day became Love & Logic… I mean like way, way, back in the early days of Design By Day, my business partner and I landed our first big break: to create the exhibition branding and materials for a Cornerhouse (now HOME) exhibition called “Unspooling: Artists & Cinema.”

It was a super exciting moment for us and we aimed to create something great for this amazing exhibition!

And we did!

It turned out that a lot of other designers thought so too. Enough so to keep on replicating our design for over a decade!

Now before I get started, I’m not going to claim credit for the concept, that was crafted by my business parter and partner in crime & design, Louise Gardner.

The exhibition sought to present contemporary artistsโ€™ current reflections and interpretations of cinema. The diamond in the brief that Louise took hold of and ran with was the following paragraph:

“The show cuts to the heart of cinema and brings out its hybrid anarchistic side, where Cinema gets a great deal of recycling and rehashing, where it explodes from its fixed and flat screen to explore new possibilities, and where we find artists who unite themselves with the cinematic more readily.”

Below you can see the brand concept designed by Louise. In my opinion, no explanation is necessary.

Unspooling poster for Cornerhouse: Unspooling Artist & Cinema exhibition: The word 'Unspooling' is displayed in white, red, yellow and blue letters, with strands of colour spreading out from some of the letters into the foreground as if they were jumping out of a cinema screen.

Copy cats

We worked on the Unspooling project back in 2011. I’m not certain when or where I first came across copies of our work, but I do recall discovering them periodically over the years and sharing the rip-offs with Louise.

A couple of weeks ago, in a WhatsApp group full of awesome graphic designers, we started discussing AI and plagiarism. Whilst this post has nothing to do with Artificial Intelligence, it does have a lot to do with plagiarism โ€“ the conversation reminded me of Unspooling.

With that in mind I decided to go on the hunt across Google Images, Pinterest and Bechance. I found so much more than i was expecting!

Now to be fair, I think some of these designs have been recreated by students. I don’t mind those โ€“ especially if they were just given a task by their teacher to replicate something as a means of learning new software. But what I do give a shit about is companies and people making money from original ideas, like this bunch:

Lovepik

Lovepik are selling this as a template on their website:

Lovepik poster template copying the Unspooling design: Chinese text meaning 'UI design recruitment' in white, red and blue letters, with coloured strands bursting out across black.

DJ Alex B

And a DJ called DJ Alex B on Pacha Recordingsย  is using a ripped off design for their track; The Music. Of course they may not be responsible for the artwork.

Cover for DJ Alex B's track 'The Music' on Pacha Recordings, copying the Unspooling style: the title in multicoloured letters with red, yellow, white and teal strands crossing black.

Collective Machine

A group called Collective Machine have stolen it for the cover art for a track called ‘Inside’. See it on Beatport.ย They even have a whole bunch of other releases with colour variations on the original! ๐Ÿ‘€

Cover art for 'Inside' by Collective Machine, copying the Unspooling design: the word 'Collective' in white and coloured outline letters, with red, yellow, teal and white strands bursting across black.Screenshot of the Beatport page for 'Inside' by Collective Machine, showing the copied cover and a row of the label's other releases using the same design in different colours.

Mensijazavcevic on Red Bubble

This ones outrageous. A person called mensijazavcevic has released a whole range of products at notorious rip-off merchant website Red Bubble.

Available to purchase are T-shirts, hoodies, posters, framed pictures, canvas mounted pictures, postcards, stickers, water bottles, caps, hats, tote bags mugs, cushions, mouse matts, phone covers, laptop cases, tapestries, socks and even matts and blankets for pets! Wild.

Two models in charcoal T-shirts printed with a copy of the design, 'Id Ego Superego' in multicoloured letters with coloured strands bursting out, sold on Redbubble.
A black mouse mat printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design, with a white mouse on a wooden desk, sold on Redbubble.
A black laptop sleeve printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design, sold on Redbubble.
A pair of black socks printed all over with the copied design, sold on Redbubble.
A phone case printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design, sold on Redbubble.
A bone-shaped pet feeding mat printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design, with a bowl of dog food, a tennis ball and a rope toy, sold on Redbubble.
A black cushion printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design on a grey sofa, sold on Redbubble.
A black mouse mat printed with the copied 'Id Ego Superego' design, with a white mouse, sold on Redbubble.

HD Graphics

And there’s more…

Like I said I’m not too bothered about the rest, neither is Louise. I’ve not looked too much into where they came from or why they had been designed. Hence why I haven’t included links to where I found them.

However, I am interesting in cataloguing them on my blog, Here’s what I have so far, found in 2023. My intention is to keep updating if/when more gems come along!

Scroll away!

Poster reading 'Adaptation' in thin multicoloured letters, with orange, blue, green and white strands crossing black in the Unspooling style.

Art Basel Miami Beach poster in the Unspooling style: 'Art Basel' in multicoloured letters with green, blue, orange and purple strands across a dark patterned background.Poster with the name 'Ayeshaa' in tall white, red, yellow and teal letters and strands bursting out across a dark background, in the Unspooling style. ย Poster titled 'Diamond Vishu' in multicoloured letters with blue, red, yellow and white strands across black, in the Unspooling style. ย French poster for the Fรชte de l'imprimerie at the Musรฉe de l'imprimerie in Nantes, Saturday 7 May 2017, free entry, with hand-drawn multicoloured lettering and coloured strands across black in the Unspooling style. Poster for Fikir Kulรผbรผ, a Turkish advertising agency, in the Unspooling style: the name in multicoloured letters with orange, green, teal and pink strands across black. ย 'Leading Lines' in multicoloured letters with yellow, pink, blue and white strands crossing a dark textured background, in the Unspooling style. Poster for the Melangart circus festival 2015 in Minsk, with the title in red and white letters and orange and white strands across a dark background, in the Unspooling style. Poster reading 'One Thing' with red, yellow, teal and white strands, Chinese text and an English Bible verse on black, in the Unspooling style. Poster reading 'Rriittiik' in tall multicoloured letters with yellow, blue, red and white strands and motivational quotes on black, in the Unspooling style. ย 'Thirty' in white, red, yellow and green letters with coloured strands bursting out across black, in the Unspooling style.

Poster with the name 'Zheyanchen' in multicoloured letters and purple, yellow, orange, teal and white strands across black, in the Unspooling style.

A navy and orange version of the Unspooling style, with Cyrillic lettering and crossing strands.

What coincidence or inspiration looks like

So back in 2017, Jack Whitehall was performing his ‘At Large’ tour. The campaign creatives had some similarities with with our Unspooling exhibition branding.

Is this plagiarism?

Probably not.

As creatives there’s so many times that we create something that has similarities with other pieces of work. And yes, it’s down right frustrating when you’ve poured your heart and soul into something, only to notice it’s similar to something else!

However, this piece of work does look significantly different to Unspooling. It was either a complete coincidence, or the desiger just took a spark of inspiration. Either way, it’s a unique piece and that’s cool with me.

Poster for Jack Whitehall's 'At Large' tour, July 2017: Jack Whitehall in a checked shirt with his arms folded on teal, beside the title in angular white and red letters with a few strands crossing behind it.

Big up Unspooling!

Besides getting noticed by those that want to recreate and rip-off, the Unspooling poster has been featured on many websites as well as Making Posters โ€“ a book by Scott Laserow and Natalia Delgado.

Page 113 of the Making Posters book shows the Unspooling poster and a write up about the techniques used.